|

Click here
for a complete schedule of activities
aco
homepage
concert
schedule
Program
notes for this concert
Essay
Coming
to America As a Composer
Essay
The
Land of Dreams?
Essay
Profile:
Fellowship Composer Jin Hi Kim
|
Immigration and the American
Compositional Dream
Through the
Lens of History
by Carol J. Oja
Immigration
has been as enriching and divisive within the American musical
experience as in the culture at large. Most residents of the United
States claim a hyphenated identity, whether African-American,
Irish-American, Jewish-American, Chinese-American, or any of the
endless spectrum of combinations. All this intermingling has produced
entirely new genres of music, from jazz to Asian hip-hop.
In the concert
world, the consequences have been profound, shifting with the
ethnicity of newly arriving immigrants. While the break with their
homelands may be definitive in a geographic sense, newcomers usually
retain a cultural tie to their roots, which can deepen as the years
pass. "I have maintained an independent stand in the way I have
syncretized my sounds," muses the Cuban-American Tania
León. "I have a blend that I feel very comfortable with
and this is very hard to explain to anyone. The sounds emerge from me
just the way that my pronunciation of English always has a touch of
an accent." The story of the music that came out of these many
"blends" is fascinating and has yet to be recounted from
the perspective of immigration history.
From the
beginning of the American republic, recent arrivals set a pattern: to
appear with a tradition from abroad, promulgate it in America, react
to surrounding impulses, and often end up with a new, hybrid product.
The Pilgrims brought with their tradition of unaccompanied psalmody
and produced the Bay Psalm Book, printed in Massachusetts in 1640. By
the late eighteenth century, British immigrants such as Alexander
Reinagle, Rayner Taylor, and Benjamin Carr played prominent roles in
shaping a vibrant concert life in burgeoning East Coast cities, and
in the nineteenth century, the arrival of German musicians such as
the Damrosch family helped spur the growth of a national network of
symphony orchestras.
In the
composition of concert music, though, it was in the twentieth century
when succeeding waves of immigrants fused with a growing native-born
pool of composers to turn the United States into a prominent musical
force. The history of the rise of American modernism centers on the
productive interactions and competitive tensions between these two groups.
In looking
back to the earliest years of the twentieth century, Americans now
take special pride in the music of Charles Ives, with its gloriously
idiosyncratic experimentations. In many ways, Ives has come to
represent the juncture of two treasured American myths: those of the
independent inventor, eccentrically but brilliantly forging new paths
and the historical superhero-a Daniel Boone or Abraham Lincoln,
etched with coonskin cap and log cabin in a gauzy daguerreotype of
cultural memory.
Less
romanticized yet equally as important to the advent of modernism in
the United States was the work of European musicians who arrived
early in the century. First came Leo Ornstein, a Ukrainian Jew who
reached America in 1907 and began introducing the American public to
musical modernism by the mid 1910s. A virtuoso pianist, he burst upon
the scene as a latter-day Liszt, wowing audiences with his keyboard
prowess while shocking them with his cluster-filled compositions.
Soon after arrived Edgard Varèse, another missionary for
modernism. Varèse's goals were to bring the newest European
compositions to New York and to generate an audience for his own
compositions. Over the course of the 1920s, his International
Composers' Guild presented New Yorkers with major new works of
Stravinsky, Schoenberg, Milhaud, Honegger, Casella, and a host of
Europeans, turning the city into an international crossroads for the
newest musical developments.
This early
generation of twentieth-century immigrants was soon eclipsed by the
arrival during the 1930s of a string of major players from Europe who
were escaping fascist regimes. Arnold Schoenberg (in 1933), Ernst
Toch (1934), Kurt Weill (1935), Ernst Krenek (1938), Igor Stravinsky
(1939), Paul Hindemith (1940). It was an imposing line-up, and it
precipitated a series of major changes in American musical culture.
On the one hand, these figures held unassailable authority as
paragons of European modernism. Many of them moved quickly into
positions at American universities, where they had a profound impact
on several generations of American composers. Their presence was
intertwined with the ascendancy of serialism in America after the
war-an issue that continues to generate contentious debate. On the
other hand, though, these composers at times fell prey to intense
nationalism. Roger Sessions, an articulate spokesperson for an
international perspective among composers complained in 1948 that the
"aggressive self-assertion" of Americans had "at least
for a time poisoned the musical atmosphere and made it one of musical
exclusiveness." In other words, the championing of national
identity among the Copland-Schuman generations could conflict with
accommodating the newest European arrivals.
By the 1960s,
a new wave of immigration was underway, made up predominantly of
Asians, Latin Americans, and West Indians, and with it, the
transplantation of European modernism to America was replaced with a
growing focus on world music traditions. This has signaled one of the
most profound changes in the history of American music. In New York
City, the percentage of immigrants in the overall population remained
fairly constant over the course of the century: 37 percent in both
1900 and 1999. Yet the countries of origin for those immigrants
changed dramatically, from a preponderance of largely eastern
European Jews and southern Italians early in the century to the
Asians and Latin Americans that continue to arrive in droves.
True to the
historical pattern, American composition continues to reverberate
from these newcomers. As in the past, most of these composers have
either fled repressive political regimes or debilitating economic
conditions-or both. Fueled by post-war American affluence and the
anti-communist passion of the Cold War, institutional support also
increased dramatically. The Rockefeller and Ford Foundations
contributed generously to promoting non-Western composers in the U.S.
and encouraging cultural exchanges with so-called Third World
countries, and countries of the former Soviet bloc. A prime example
of this has been the Center for U.S.-China Arts Exchange, based at
Columbia University and led by composer Chou Wen-chung, which has
assisted a major influx of Chinese composers to America, affecting
the careers of such composers as Bright Sheng, Zhou Long, Tan Dun,
and Chen Yi.
These days,
there's a booming audience for cross-cultural musics, and it shows up
across genres. In the concert world, the Kronos Quartet has issued
CDs such as "Pieces of Africa" and "Kronos
Caravan" that feature composers from outside of the West. The
ACO has fostered these same goals, whether through commissions to
composers such as Ge Gan-ru and Bun-ching Lam or through its Sonidos
de las Américas, which focuses on composers of the Caribbean,
Central America, and South America. The Sonidos celebration in 1999
brought more than fifty Cuban artists to New York. There, not only
were cultural intersections encouraged but lines between musical
genres were blurred. The festival included concert composers, yes,
but also folk and jazz musicians, aiming for a boundary-free
celebration of a vibrant musical tradition.
Yet the
celebration of cultural difference remains a volatile political issue
in America. These new showcases for diversity provide immigrant
composers with a kind of visibility and ethnic validation that often
eluded their predecessors at the same time as the overall national
climate about immigration remains politically charged. We've moved
from the assimilating forces of the "melting pot," as the
early twentieth-century immigrant scene was dubbed, to recognition of
ethnic identity, at the same time, as we have no clear national
consensus about issues such as educating Hispanic students in Spanish.
In other
words, the process of adjusting to a new culture remains agitating.
"I am in constant transit!" exclaims Tania Léon,
articulating a sensation felt acutely by all those who have stepped
onto the roller coaster of geographic displacement. There's no
question, though, that American music continues to benefit from the ride.
-Carol J.
Oja is author of Making Music Modern: New York in the 1920s (Oxford
University Press)
|